Skip to main content
‹ Back to the archive
Civic Tech PlatformsCouncil-procured

Polco Comparison Groups / Track dashboard

civic-tech-platforms · USA (Madison, WI HQ; 500+ municipal clients) · Comparison Groups feature released 2023, expanded 2024

Polco is a civic engagement and benchmarking platform for local governments. The Track dashboard lets a city/school district pick up to 9 peer jurisdictions and compare side-by-side on community survey results (NCS), financial health, demographics, and policy outcomes. School-district dashboards filter survey data by neighbourhood, race, gender, age. Layered onto Polco's survey/budget-simulation engagement tools.

Areas compete

Track explicitly compares a municipality against up to 9 peer cities or counties of similar 'geotype' on the same metrics, exposing where your city ranks. NCS benchmarks include 'quality of neighborhood' as a tracked dimension that produces inter-area scoring at both city and intra-city level.

People support each other

Within each jurisdiction, the platform aggregates input from many residents - the score only moves when many neighbours fill out a survey or weigh in on a budget. Comparison Groups motivate municipal staff and councils to recruit broader participation from their own community to improve the metric.

Why this is worth knowing

One of the cleanest examples of a civic-tech product turning 'compare us to similar peer areas' into a first-class UI feature. Useful counterexample: comparison is between jurisdictions (cities/districts), not residents - close analogue to a BelongHub town leaderboard.

StatusLive (active platform, comparison groups GA)
YearComparison Groups feature released 2023, expanded 2024
WhereUSA (Madison, WI HQ; 500+ municipal clients)
Effort to start a local versionCouncil-procured
LanguageEnglish
Verificationhigh confidence
Adjacent

Others in the same family

CitizenLab / Go Vocal Representativeness Dashboard

Civic Tech Platforms · Belgium (Brussels HQ); deployed in Brussels, Leuven, Mechelen, Wallonia, etc.

Belgian civic-engagement SaaS used by cities across Europe to run consultations, ideation, participatory budgeting. The Representativeness Dashboard compares each participating cohort's demographics (age, gender, neighbourhood, education) against the underlying ward/postcode-level population so cities can see which neighbourhoods are over- or under-represented in real time, and target outreach.

ioby (in our backyards) - civic crowdfunding with city match funds

Civic Tech Platforms · USA - HQ Brooklyn/Memphis/Detroit; deployed in Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Lorain County OH, NYC, etc.

Civic crowdfunding platform combined with grassroots coaching. Local 'Leaders' propose neighbourhood projects (community gardens, murals, after-school programs). City partners offer 'Match Funds' (e.g. One Northside Crowdfunding Challenge in Pittsburgh, Lorain County Match Fund) where neighbourhoods compete for matching capital pools. Average donation $35, $21M+ raised, most donors live within 2 miles of the project.

Decidim process-groups + Barcelona/Helsinki/NYC participatory budgeting district tiers

Civic Tech Platforms · Barcelona ES, Helsinki FI, NYC USA (Decidim/Consul deployments)

Decidim's 'process groups' feature is explicitly designed for grouping parallel participatory budgets per district/neighbourhood. NYC's PB ran in 30 of 51 council districts in 2021-22, each with at least $1M to spend, residents drop pins on a map to pitch ideas. Helsinki's OmaStadi splits city budget by area (Itäinen, Eteläinen, Pohjoinen, etc.) with separate ideation, deliberation and vote per area.

Defi Ensemble, on bouge (ParticipACTION Community Challenge)

Health & Public Good · Canada (all provinces + territories)

Every June, Canadian communities (cities, towns, First Nations, rural municipalities) log physical-activity minutes via the ParticipACTION app to compete for the title of 'Canada's Most Active Community' and a CAD $100,000 prize, plus 12 regional prizes ($5k-$10k) for the most active community in each province/territory. Quebec City won the 'most active community in Quebec' prize multiple times. Over $1.5m awarded to 49 communities since 2019; $7.2m in grants for follow-on local sport initiatives.

PulsePoint Respond / AED

Health & Public Good · USA, Canada, UK, Australia (4,500+ agencies)

911-connected app that, when a public-place cardiac arrest is dispatched, alerts every CPR-trained user within ~500m of the patient and routes them to the nearest registered AED. >4m users; ~1m responders dispatched to 294,000 cardiac-arrest events by Nov 2024. Cities/counties/agencies adopt PulsePoint as a public-health infrastructure.

Stadtradeln (City Cycling)

Fitness & Movement · Germany (3,000+ municipalities) + Klima-Bündnis cities worldwide

21-day campaign by Klima-Bündnis e.V. where cities and rural districts compete on how many bike-kilometers their residents collectively log via app. Schools, clubs, companies, citizen groups form sub-teams under their municipality's banner.